January 29, 2013
By: Bob Sikes – Scathing Purple Musings
Jeff Solochek of Gradebook calls attention to those reading scores everyone’s been bragging about for the last month.
Florida’s fourth graders are the second-best readers in the world, Gov. Rick Scott claimed during a recent discussion with black lawmakers.
That’s pretty great news, right? Well, hold on just a second.
Our friends at PolitiFact Florida investigated the claim to determine just how accurate it actually is.
While they deemed the facts of his claim are mostly correct, they said Scott stretched the truth a bit because the study doesn’t include every country – or even every state.
As it turns out, Florida is the only state which was included in the study.
Why? We paid.
“Scott would have been correct to say Florida finished second in the study, but he stretched the truth a bit when he said Florida ranked second in the world,” PolitiFact concluded.
Florida used $1.9 million of it’s Race to the Top grant to pay for what’s essentially been used as talking points to defend the Florida Model. Let’s take at a few examples.
* Florida board of education chairman Gary Chartrand opened the public hearing during which current education commissioner Tony Bennett was interviewed with “the good news.” Former chair and long-time associate Kathleen Shanahan touted the news as justification for Florida’s reforms and that they ought to end debate.
* The Florida Department of Education has a CNN report touting the results on it’s website. To then interim commissioner Pam Stewart’s credit, she attributed the results to classroom interventions and focus by teachers.
* Jeb Bush’s foundation blog used the results to criticize Diane Ravitch. John Kirtley’sredefinED used the same post to call out Florida’s teachers and FEA president And Ford for “not celebrating teacher success.”
There are others. So why invest so much money in a survey which doesn’t even compare Florida to any other state? Who made the decision to do so? The flawed wisdom in doing so is evident in that NAEP – a much more reliable and accepted measure – was showing the same thing.
Both comments and pings are currently closed.